All picks

Baseball · MLB ·

Cincinnati Reds vs St. Louis Cardinals

Pick
St. Louis Cardinals ML
Line
-136
Bet type
Game
Status
WIN
CLV
+0.3%
Key points — 5
  1. 01Tonight's pitching matchup tilts heavily toward St. Louis. Kyle Leahy carries a 4.25 ERA across 55 innings this season, but his recent work is sharper, a 2.81 ERA over his last 5 starts. Cincinnati counters with Brady Singer, who has been hit hard: a 6.18 season ERA over 51 innings.
  2. 02Singer's recent form is alarming. His last 5 starts produced a 7.77 ERA with the trend worsening, his most recent 2 starts sit at 8.00 versus 7.71 in the older pair, so there's no improvement to lean on. He's surrendered 11 home runs across that window, and his 9.28 FIP says the runs are earned, not unlucky.
  3. 03The bat-the-margins late-game edge belongs to St. Louis. The Cardinals' ninth-inning role is established with Riley O'Brien as the closer, carrying 15 saves and a workable 3.95 season ERA. Cincinnati, by contrast, runs an unsettled ninth-inning role, Tony Santillan tops their leverage chart but carries a 6.65 ERA and a brutal 14.73 mark over his last 10. That's a vulnerable pen in tight late innings.
  4. 04The offensive form gap is wide. St. Louis grades at -38 over the last week, ugly but far better than Cincinnati's -90, the kind of slump number that signals a lineup in freefall. The Reds also rank 27 in team batting average and 25 in on-base, they don't manufacture runs against quality arms.
  5. 05The market price is fair-to-favorable on the Cardinals. St. Louis sits -136 at home, with a 16-12 mark and the better starter, better closer, and better recent offensive pulse. Busch Stadium's 0.87 HR factor further suppresses Singer's lone path back into the game, the longball, limiting Cincinnati's upside against a pitcher who keeps it in the yard.

§ 01The analysis

The pitching and bullpen edges both point the same direction. Leahy isn't an ace, but his recent 2.81 ERA against Singer's deteriorating 7.77 last-5 mark, backed by a 9.28 FIP, is a meaningful gap the run line and moneyline reflect only partially. Cincinnati's offense is the league's coldest right now at -90, and their unsettled ninth-inning role with Santillan's 14.73 recent ERA gives St. Louis the late-game leverage. The model pegs fair home ML at 58.8%, just above the -136 implied price of 57.6%. That's a thin edge, but every secondary signal, closer quality, offense form, starter form, reinforces the same side rather than contradicting it. With odds inside the -150 floor, the Cardinals are playable.

§ 02The call

St. Louis owns the cleaner starter, the established closer, and the warmer bat against the league's coldest lineup. The risk is Leahy's own shaky season ERA and the modest edge size. But the signals align cleanly and the price sits inside our floor. Take the Cardinals.

Final resultWINSt. Louis Cardinals ML · -136
Graded Jun 6, 2026

Get the daily card before kickoff

Subscribe