All picks

Baseball · MLB ·

St. Louis Cardinals vs Milwaukee Brewers

Pick
Over 8
Line
-105
Bet type
Game
Status
LOSS
CLV
+0.0%
Key points — 5
  1. 01Kyle Harrison has been dominant for Milwaukee, a 1.77 ERA across 45.7 innings with a 31.3% strikeout rate and a sparkling 0.96 ERA over his last 5 starts. He's a lefty, and the Cardinals grade at just +20 vs LHP across 253 PA, notably worse than their +37 vs righties.
  2. 02Michael McGreevy counters with a 2.40 ERA across 56.3 innings, but the underlying numbers scream regression, his profile is toward-worse with a 4.04 FIP and a 5.86 xERA, a large gap. His last 5 ERA sits at 1.55 but the trend is worsening, newer 2 starts at 3.27 vs older 2 at 0.75.
  3. 03McGreevy doesn't miss bats, 6.83 K/9 over his last 5 and a 7.69% swinging-strike rate. Milwaukee's lineup grades at +28 vs RHP across 620 PA, and Brice Turang in particular has crushed righties to a 1.032 OPS across 152 PA. William Contreras (.810 OPS vs RHP) and Jake Bauers (.854 OPS) round out a contact-friendly platoon spot.
  4. 04Weather and park lean Over-friendly. Wind blowing out to left at 6.7 mph in 83°F air, with American Family Field's HR factor of 1.10 for righties, and Milwaukee's lineup is RHB-heavy against this lefty. Roof open, no precip at 0%.
  5. 05Bullpens are reasonably rested, Milwaukee ranks 24 in usage, St. Louis 20, but the high-leverage arms aren't airtight. Trevor Megill carries a 5.29 season ERA heading Milwaukee's ninth-inning committee, and St. Louis closer Riley O'Brien's 2.96 ERA masks a 5.40 mark over his last 10.

§ 01The analysis

The Over case rests on McGreevy's regression profile being one of the loudest in our data, a 1.64-run ERA-FIP gap and nearly 3.5 runs of ERA-xERA separation across a meaningful 10-start sample. Milwaukee's righty bats have the platoon edge against him, the park amplifies RHB power, and a 6.7 mph breeze out to left fits Turang/Bauers/Yelich pull-side lefty barrels into the gap too. The counter is real: Harrison has been excellent and the Cardinals slip against LHP, which caps the away side's run expectation. But that's why we're at 8.4, not 9.0, the home side's offensive lean alone justifies pushing through the 8.0 line, with McGreevy's underlying form as the lever. Both committee/closer arms have warts. Book at 8 underprices the combination.

§ 02The call

McGreevy is overperforming his peripherals by a huge margin, Milwaukee's righty-loaded lineup gets the platoon edge, the park plays up for RHB power, and the wind nudges carry to left. Risk: Harrison is genuinely good and could hold the Cardinals to 1-2 runs, making this a 4-3 type game. We'll take the price.

Final resultLOSSOver 8 · -105
Graded May 27, 2026

Get the daily card before kickoff

Subscribe